IBN S?QAWAYH

IBN S?QAWAYH (wrongly Ibn Saquya or Ibn Saquyah or Ibn Sakuyah ; early 10^th century), Karaite scholar in Babylonia or a neighboring country, contemporary of Saadiah *Gaon. In his objections to the Oral Law and those who rely on it, Ibn S?qawayh used the Mishnah and Talmud to prove that in their commentaries the *Rabbanites distort Scripture and that the Oral Law was not revealed to Moses at Sinai. He cites a number of talmudic legends to demonstrate that the Rabbanites invested God with human attributes. He collected the legends from the Talmud and midrashim which he considered curious in order to support his arguments against the Oral Law in Kit?b al-Fa???i? ("Book of Shame"). Saadiah Gaon answered his allegations in Kit?b al-Radd ?al? Ibn S?qawayh ("Response to Ibn S?qawayh") in which he rejects Ibn S?qawayh's arguments against the Oral Law and his objections to several halakhot. Saadiah's Kit?b al-Radd ?al? al-Muta??mil ?ala al-Mishnah wa-al-Talm?d ("Response to the Challenger of the Mishnah and the Talmud") is possibly also an answer to Ibn S?qawayh. However, the interrelationship of these writings is not clear. Passages from Saadiah's writings were found in the Cairo *Genizah whereas Ibn S?qawayh's are known only through quotations made by his opponents.

bibliography:

S. Pozna?ski, Karaite Literary Opponents of Saadiah Gaon (1908), 4–8; Assaf, in: Tarbiz, 4 (1932/33), 35–53, 193–206; Mann, Texts, index; Zucker, in: paajr, 18 (1949), 1–4; L. Nemoy, Karaite Anthology (1952), 70, 234, 376.